PDA

View Full Version : Final Thoughts From A Departing Player


FBG_Winston_Wolfe
07-01-2007, 08:13 PM
In an effort to still be helpful, I am making one final post.

I was part of the FBGs invasion of the first incarnation of Everwars back in 2003. I quickly became addicted and enjoyed the game. Back then, there were a couple of monthly tournaments that gave players a chance to get in on the action at the beginning of every month. After a while, the game seemed abandoned by the devs and monthly resets never happened. I drifted away, but not completely. I checked back in from time to time always disappointed seeing the "New Tournament Beginning in Nov 2003" at the top of the page.

Fast forward to April 2007, FBGOnetime announces on another board that Everwars is back. There was much rejoicing. The new game requires recruiting. In an effort to compete with the uber recruiters, I created multiple accounts. FBG_Citizen Juicer and Dalton. I did this entirely for the Silver Prizes.

I was an addicted player that would check in every 5 hours in order to not lose my coveted battle credits so I would not lose ground and I so I could move up the rankings. This bears repeating. I was logging in EVERY 5 hours and battle or so in order to not lose BCs. I even set my alarm so that I could wake up early.

The ranking system was changed to king of the hill and I was still an addicted player. I was saving money so that I could compete with the large sword monkeys. I was working towards a goal.

The new ranking system is implemented, stamina is implemented, a battle timer is implemented, skills are revamped and Everpoints are introduced. I was not completely happy with the battle timer, but completely understand server load. A stamina bug is discovered and stamina is disabled. This is where many a player went into limbo. No one knew what changes were going to be made. There was no "incentive" to attack players that you might lose to. Item costs in the shop were too expensive, so saving your EPs at two and hour (IIRC) was not an option.

What came next was farming. I and many other players chose to attack low level I players at 50% strength gaining equipment, skill points in abundance. Why did I do it? Because it allowed me to improve my character and it gave me something to do without having to wait around for the battle timer, which I felt impeded the enjoyment of the game.

Farming was corrected, and the non farmers in the top 25 were rewarded. This didn't bother me because I was not top 25 before farming, and the rewards that I reaped were far in excess of the special prize still not determined. On the forums, it was "perceived" that the Devs were "punishing" certain players. I'm not implying that's what happened. I am stating that is how I perceived it.

I was losing interested in the game, but I was holding out hope that the new stamina system would add the fun back to the game. Unfortunately, the EPs were limited to 1 every hour if you did not click a button every ten minutes. At the current stage of game development, there is/was not enough to do on the site to keep a player occupied very long. I tried to stay on the site as much as possible in order to earn EPs. This is where the game took a turn for the worse, IMO. I had gone from being addicted to the site and wanting to battle, to becoming a "click monkey". Click a button every ten minutes, collect your reward. I am well aware that the majority of my boredom was the result of being well equipped and the game being less than 10% complete.

In my boredom, I did two things.
1) I created another user in order to gain prize codes. This one was named "Donna"
2) I wrote a script so that I did not have to visit the site in order to collect maximum EPs.

I want to be clear. I did this because I was bored with the current status of the game and I was holding out hope that the future update would bring the fun back into the game.

Fast forward to today. I finally see that the long awaited update has gone live. I see that I no longer have equipment and my EPs are severely less than I should have accrued. I go and read the updates and I see that the database has been reset. I can't say that it surprised me. You can't really beta test a game, when the majority of the players already have advanced characters have surpassed the early stages of character development. The core has been completely rewritten, it needs to be tested. As I said, I am not at all surprised that the database was wiped.

I check out the new features of the game, and I am encouraged by the changes. Upon reading Zeras' post, part of it caught my eye.


However, we became aware of a few exploits about 3 weeks ago that were being abused by users. One of these in particular was being used by several members. When we found it about 3 weeks ago, we activated extended logging to see just how many users were taking advantage of it. To our surprise, there were over 150 users exploiting the bug. As a result, that convinced us the only fair thing to do for the rest of the honest players was to go with the database wipe.


I went into chat and Sadistic was there. I tried to relay that the bolded part came across as "punishment" and it would probably be perceived in a way that was not intended. From the get go, Sadistic was combative with me, called me a cheater and pretty much take a hike.

Not once did I say that I felt it was unfair or that it shouldn't be done. I only repeated that my "perception" was that the bolded part above came across as punishment. I have been around these boards since mid April, one thing that I have noted is that the Devs sometimes come across in ways that are not intended, and tend to come across in certain situations as combative.

I used to be the head administrator for a message board that usually had 500-1000 users as any given time. I have a lot of experience in how the typed word can come across the wrong way. I hope the Devs take this as a constructive post. IMO, you really need to work on your message board communication skills, because at this early stage, every miscommunication has the potential of driving a future customer away.

My reason for leaving has nothing to do with my exchange with Sadistic or any issue with any Dev. My reason for leaving is simple. The current maximum EP you can earn in an hour is 6. That equates to a maximum of 2 battles earned in an hour. This is too slow to keep my interest. This game has amazing potential.

My suggestion for the Devs is to increase the EP earning rate until other aspects of the game are implemented. I fear that the game action is moving too slow to keep users coming back.

I wish the best for Devs and hope this game is a success in the future.

Sadistic
07-01-2007, 08:20 PM
I did call you a cheater, yes. I did not "go off" on you. I'm too damn old to go off on someone.

And after I did call you a cheater, you admitted to cheating.

I don't care what you think of me, nor do I have any pitty for you, but in all honesty... You need to stop lying to yourself. You cheated, and that's the end of it. You're always going to be a cheater because of that. The true tradgedy is that all the FBG's look bad because of it, and most of you guys seem like you're pretty cool, including you.

I'm sure this reply will just get turned around to me bashing you, and being combative.

Like I said before in the chat, take it as you will.

Oh, and as my last point... I didn't tell you to leave, I wanted to avoid the conversatoin that was taking place. You wanted to persue it. That was your choice. I'm sorry to see you leave. I was looking forward to fighting with the FBG's in a solid CGE, like in the first EW.

Gil
07-01-2007, 08:28 PM
Winston, Thanks for taking the time to post this in a constructive and civilized manner.

We even read and listen to these posts as well. Take care.

Shardnax
07-01-2007, 09:27 PM
Hm, I think I'll join in on quitting, Sadistic, stop acting like you honestly care, as it makes you look like a prick. As a side note for the administrative folk, back up the database every month. You can fall back on it when someone cheats and that way you don't have people spending time only to have it wasted on your stupidity. If you can't catch and stop a cheater within a month, you aren't putting much effort forth.

Cheers Fools.

Sadistic
07-01-2007, 09:30 PM
Am I really that transparent?

Oh well...

Aonghus
07-01-2007, 09:34 PM
9
Sadistic attacks using Bronze Bastard Sword for 4 damage
3
9
Aonghus attacks using Iron Great Axe for 3 damage
0
I passed the stupidity test. That being said Im going to show my intelligence again, with a nice tootles for EW.

FBG_OChaos
07-02-2007, 07:47 AM
I am going to also fade into darkness with regards to this game.

It has been no secret that I have have been aggressive with the Dev's on the forums, but that has nothing to do with my decision.

When I saw the post from FBG_OneTime and decided to come back to this game, I thought it was a easy, fun timewaster of a game that ties in well with my competitive spirit. It took a long time to build my character into the 100's, but it was a good time IMO.

Then, when the game changed to king of the hill, I loved it as I could get and stay on the first page, it was fun, yet still a good timewaster game.

When the game changed to limit the battles to two minutes apart is when it started to lose it luster for me.

This game appears to be evolving into a nice product, but it is nothing near what drew me to it. I was looking for a good timewaster that I didnt have to dedicate alot of time playing (a la World of Warcraft etc..) and EW provided that, but after gearing up my character today and fighting a few battles, it is clear to me that this game is not for me anymore and it will continue to move away from the timewaster direction to a complete MMORG.

Good luck to the devs on what will surley be a sucessfull game once you get it complete, I just think that it will draw a much different crowd then you currently have..

Thanks for all the work you have put into the game, even through the complaining, I still enjoyed the competitve spirit.

geezer
07-02-2007, 02:28 PM
I am also adding my name to the list of dearly departed. While I hope I am wrong, I do not believe this will ever be a viable product. You developers are cool-coding the fun right out of it. I wish you the best of luck.

Gryffyn
07-02-2007, 04:31 PM
Bwahahaha!

Sorry, I'm having to stifle my laughter. "Taking the fun out of it"? Pfft, please. Yeah, that's what the Devs are trying to do. I can see a typical meeting now which is, of course, occurring in the bowels of Hell, in the third conference room (the other two were being used by the committee for genocide and the committees for famine and pestilence). Zeras sits facing Gil.

Zeras: So, how can we trick people into playing this completely not fun game?
Gil: Hmm, how bout we give them little rewards when they do good? Then, get them hooked on the game and change it up so completely so they aren't enjoying the game, but it's too late because they're hooked?
Zeras: I love it! All of the negative vibes we'll get will fuel our doomsday machine! They won't know what hit them!
Gil: Next, we'll jump start Carrot Top's career and our plans for world domination will be complete! Bwahaha!

C'mon, folks, like Axl once pleaded, "Just a little patience..."

Edited for spelling

Eve
07-02-2007, 04:45 PM
Funny, that's exactly how our meetings go...

:);)

Dragother
07-02-2007, 07:34 PM
Bwahahaha!

Sorry, I'm having to stifle my laughter. "Taking the fun out of it"? Pfft, please. Yeah, that's what the Devs are trying to do. I can see a typical meeting now which is, of course, occurring in the bowels of Hell, in the third conference room (the other two were being used by the committee for genocide and the committees for famine and pestilence). Zeras sits facing Gil.

Zeras: So, how can we trick people into playing this completely not fun game?
Gil: Hmm, how bout we give them little rewards when they do good? Then, get them hooked on the game and change it up so completely so they aren't enjoying the game, but it's too late because they're hooked?
Zeras: I love it! All of the negative vibes we'll get will fuel our doomsday machine! They won't know what hit them!
Gil: Next, we'll jump start Carrot Top's career and our plans for world domination will be complete! Bwahaha!

C'mon, folks, like Axl once pleaded, "Just a little patience..."

Edited for spelling
Hey he was just stating his opinino on the changes, no need to gun him down. I'm sure the devs figured not everyone was going to be happy with the changes and steeled their hearts accordingly. ;)

It's a bummer that some of the guys that have been here for while and have provided good input have decided to leave, but we can't exactly nail them to the floor here now can we?

ummm...are we sure we can't do that? I mean it might not be a bad idea...

kidseatfree
07-02-2007, 09:02 PM
This game appears to be evolving into a nice product, but it is nothing near what drew me to it. I was looking for a good timewaster that I didnt have to dedicate alot of time playing (a la World of Warcraft etc..) and EW provided that, but after gearing up my character today and fighting a few battles, it is clear to me that this game is not for me anymore and it will continue to move away from the timewaster direction to a complete MMORG.

Good luck to the devs on what will surley be a sucessfull game once you get it complete, I just think that it will draw a much different crowd then you currently have..

Thanks for all the work you have put into the game, even through the complaining, I still enjoyed the competitve spirit.

Good post! And I mean that.

This post (mine) is not necessarily directed to the one I quoted.

I, myself, am going NOWHERE.

From the beginning the devs have stated this game was to be completely different from the original EW. Sure, things have changed a lot. And that's a-ok. In fact, it's to be expected. It's in beta. And it may be in beta a LONG time. But, if the recent change is an indication of whats to come, I can see myself playing this game, and having to change strategies as I go, a long time. Even though I don't have the inside info on future plans, we've been told they are coming and I know the game will only get deeper, yet still easy to play. I have complete faith in the development team that they will deliver on this game.

We've been asked to give feedback. But, in the end we should accept that the final decisions are those of the devs. If you don't like what you see, state your opinion, give suggestions, then MOVE ON. Don't take it personal. I've held my tongue on a lot of stuff... only to see that most of it gets implemented or is even implemented better than I could've thought of. I also realize there's more stuff on their "to do" list than we know and that we WON'T know til their ready.

I'm honored to even be a part of this beta. I'm not on as often as I want to be, but I enjoy this game when I am (especially with the new update). I can understand how frustrating it can be to give so much time to this project, only to get numerous complaints rather than feedback.

Go with your original plans and ideas.... implementing those new ones you receive that fit into the big picture of the game. You might lose a certain group of players, but you'll most certainly draw a new group, better suited to this game.

And really... it's a game we're helping to mold. Enjoy the journey people.

Gil
07-02-2007, 09:22 PM
Summon forth Carrot Top, I have a mission for him...

Gil
07-02-2007, 09:27 PM
In all seriousness, we understand some of the changes we make may not be well received. But we have a plan and we are going to implement it and hopefully people will like it. Along the way, we are open to ideas and suggestions (some of which have made their way into the game) but in the end, we are going to take a shot at this and we will either succeed or fail.

Only time will tell.

To those leaving, take care and maybe one day you might see us still around and come back for a look so you can fulfil your own morbid curiousity and chuckle over our demise OR come back and join us in our success.

Gryffyn
07-02-2007, 09:57 PM
Hey he was just stating his opinino on the changes, no need to gun him down. I'm sure the devs figured not everyone was going to be happy with the changes and steeled their hearts accordingly. ;)

It's a bummer that some of the guys that have been here for while and have provided good input have decided to leave, but we can't exactly nail them to the floor here now can we?

ummm...are we sure we can't do that? I mean it might not be a bad idea...

Believe me, that wasn't even close to me gunning anyone down.

I'm just making light of this mentality of "I don't like the way the game is going now and I don't feel like waiting to see the end result, so I'm taking my ball and going home." Stating an opinion is one thing, quitting b/c you don't like the game is certainly your choice, but doing it before the game is in it's final form is weak.

That's why I said "patience, patience.."

FBG_OChaos
07-02-2007, 10:34 PM
Believe me, that wasn't even close to me gunning anyone down.

I'm just making light of this mentality of "I don't like the way the game is going now and I don't feel like waiting to see the end result, so I'm taking my ball and going home." Stating an opinion is one thing, quitting b/c you don't like the game is certainly your choice, but doing it before the game is in it's final form is weak.

That's why I said "patience, patience.."

I had to log back in to reply to this post...

How long have you been her n00b? With only 5 posts and 2 being in this thread, you have no ground to stand on what is "weak", have you put the last few months of grinding your way to and sticking at the top of this game?

Once you have done that, please post back and say what is weak about players who choose to leave...

Alot of these players, especially some of those departing in this thread have spent alot of time on this game either playing, taunting, exploiting, giving feedback etc.., all which have helped form the game you are playing today.

Say what you want, this game isnt for everyone, I for one know that if I am going to play, I want to be on top, but to do that will require more time then I can commit, so thats why I am leaving, others have different reasons. When it comes down to it, everyone has to decide what they want out of a game and if that game no longer provides that, then you stop playing. Its pretty straight forward IMO..

I'll probably check back from time to time to see how the game is going, but you wont see my W/L record change.. good luck.

Gryffyn
07-03-2007, 11:37 AM
I had to log back in to reply to this post...

How long have you been her n00b? With only 5 posts and 2 being in this thread, you have no ground to stand on what is "weak", have you put the last few months of grinding your way to and sticking at the top of this game?

Once you have done that, please post back and say what is weak about players who choose to leave...

Alot of these players, especially some of those departing in this thread have spent alot of time on this game either playing, taunting, exploiting, giving feedback etc.., all which have helped form the game you are playing today.

Say what you want, this game isnt for everyone, I for one know that if I am going to play, I want to be on top, but to do that will require more time then I can commit, so thats why I am leaving, others have different reasons. When it comes down to it, everyone has to decide what they want out of a game and if that game no longer provides that, then you stop playing. Its pretty straight forward IMO..

I'll probably check back from time to time to see how the game is going, but you wont see my W/L record change.. good luck.

Ah, since I have only posted a couple of times, I'm a "noob". Brilliant analysis. Astounding depth and insightfulness...but wildly inaccurate. Been involved since April of this year (hey, just like you), and watching from the outside for longer than that. Never made it to the top, though I did crack the top 30 a couple of times. Guess I wasn't uber enough. I know I haven't been involved as long as some here, but I'm by no means a "noob". Perhaps I wasn't saying anything because I had nothing to add. The concerns or thoughts I was having were addressed by in large other people.

Hey, you don't like the game and want to leave, fine. It sucks you can't wait to see how things are gonna shake out, see what the end result is gonna be, but hey, more power to ya'. It's just grating to see all the whining about how the game sucks or I can't attack fast enough, etc. Jeez, folks, give it a chance. It's been two freaking days...

And yes, I understand people haven't liked the way the game was going for sometime so this is just the culmination of everything for them. I just think some people are being a bit close-minded.


Edited for spelling

Dellen
07-03-2007, 12:12 PM
Batten down the hatches! The games gonna sink with all these people jumping on the bandwagon.

Seriously, some people are offended by the mods attitudes towards them. They have every right to be upset, they have been working on this game, for what, over 5 years I would assume, and while most people have been very understanding, and even upbeat about the changes. Some people continue to gripe, and complain, and threaten to go home because they are not winning. It's like the people who get beat in chess, and instead of playing again, throw the board and knock the pieces around like a spoiled child.

If you dont want to play, dont play...If you do want to play, then realize that theres gonna be some things that arent perfect yet. It's Beta, which means it's an unfinished product that is currently being refined and tuned to the programers liking. If you wish to offer suggestions to make things better, then make them critically, with thorough research and thought. Not, I think we should get EP's every minute, and UR items with every spellcode. Think about the reasons behind it, why it needs to be changed, if the reason it's this way is to keep balance later on, or if it's just too much of a rewrite to fix. Zeras, Gil, Eve, Sadistic, and I think atleast one more person, are quite active in responding to our suggestions, theres not many, if any, games out there where this is the case.

The nicer you are about suggestions, the more likely they are to be considered. If you are combative, even if you have valid points, they tend to be overlooked because of the agressiveness. Just log in, have fun, if your goal is to be the best, then strive for #1, if your goal is to make friends, then make friends...But the overall goal is to have fun, thats what games are for. Some people take them WAY too seriously...

deathbagel
07-03-2007, 11:50 PM
Gryff got called a n00b! bwahaha!

bwahaha!

bwahaha!

ok, I'm done now.

Sorry to see ya go Onetime, honestly, hope you change your mind down the road and come back.

FBGOnetime
07-03-2007, 11:55 PM
Gryff got called a n00b! bwahaha!

bwahaha!

bwahaha!

ok, I'm done now.

Sorry to see ya go Onetime, honestly, hope you change your mind down the road and come back.

Who said I was leaving:cool:

deathbagel
07-03-2007, 11:56 PM
Who said I was leaving:cool:Gah, I meant Winston.. I just wish you'd leave.. you always beat up on me.. /cry ;)

:)

Gryffyn
07-04-2007, 02:17 PM
Gryff got called a n00b! bwahaha!



I got your n00b here...whatever the hell that means.

And stop stealing my laugh. I rightfully stole it from Dr. Doom and the mid to late '80's Justice League.:p